Kismet, New York is the westernmost settlement on Fire Island, a picturesque barrier island stretching over 30 miles off the southern coast of Long Island, New York. This charming spot has a rich history, having been inhabited for centuries, first by Native Americans, and later by Dutch settlers. For over a hundred years, Kismet has thrived as a vibrant community on the island’s western edge.
A significant portion of Fire Island is managed by the National Park Service as the Fire Island National Seashore, which makes it a must-visit for avid National Park enthusiasts like myself. Despite being well-known to locals, Kismet exudes the ambiance of a hidden gem, reminiscent of a quaint New England coastal town.
Getting to Kismet is part of the adventure. Standard vehicles are not permitted on the island unless you have a government authorization or a special permit, contributing to the settlement’s unique, laid-back vibe. The island’s marina bustles with fishing and recreational boats, setting the stage for an idyllic retreat.
A distinctive feature of Kismet is the abundance of wagons. You’ll often see locals and visitors alike pulling these handy carts filled with goods. There’s even designated “wagon parking” near the settlement’s “downtown”—a charming touch that adds to the community feel.
I was particularly charmed by the beach cruiser bicycles dotting the island. People here truly embrace island life, and cycling is a perfect way to get around the area. The beach, stretching long and beautiful, was wonderfully serene when we visited off-season.
To reach Kismet, you have two main options:
1. By Ferry: Regular ferries depart from Bay Shore to various settlements on Fire Island. Schedules are frequent during the busy summer months but become sporadic during the off-season, so plan accordingly.
2. By Foot via Robert Moses State Park: While cars aren’t allowed throughout most of the island, you can drive to Robert Moses State Park on the western side. From there, it’s a pleasant, short walk—less than a mile—to Kismet, with the opportunity to visit the lighthouse along the way. However, reaching more inland settlements would require a longer trek.
Don’t forget, Fire Island is also home to the Fire Island National Seashore, managed by the National Park Service. If you’re collecting National Park Cancellation Stamps, be sure to stop by one of the visitor centers scattered around the island.
